"I presume there was no mirror in your dressing room tonight." Simon Cowell to Sanjaya

1. Beautiful - Christina Aguilera
2. Elizabeth, You Were Born To Play That Part - Ryan Adams
3. The Lighthouse's Tale - Nickel Creek
4. My Town - Montgomery Gentry
5. But You Know I Love You - Alison Krauss
6. Closing Time - Tom Waits
7. New Years Day - U2
8. Walk On The Ocean - Toad the Wet Sprocket
9. 83 - John Mayer (Serendipity Soundtrack)
10. Man In The Mirror - Michael Jackson

Bonus: Something To Be Proud Of - Montgomery Gentry